Pure Joy Ice Cream sits on North Broadway in the heart of downtown Siloam Springs, Arkansas, a short walk from the town’s restaurants. After dinner down the street at Fratelli’s, my wife and I wandered over for dessert on our birthday-getaway weekend.
Jump to Section
From a Hobby to a Downtown Scoop Shop


Pure Joy started as a hobby. Matt and Meghan Feyerabend were making ice cream at home when they scooped it in public for the first time at a fundraiser for friends adopting a little girl whose middle name was Joy. The name stuck, and it carries a double meaning: the joy of that moment and the pure, from-scratch ingredients behind every batch.
By 2012 they were selling small batches at Northwest Arkansas festivals like Fayetteville’s Roots Festival, then landed wholesale accounts with local grocers and pie shops. When Whole Foods asked Pure Joy to start supplying its stores, the Feyerabends knew it was time for a kitchen of their own. In 2017, they restored a historic building on North Broadway, topped it with a retro neon sign, and opened their downtown scoop shop.
Local sourcing is the throughline, and Meghan’s Cherokee heritage runs through it. A Cherokee Nation citizen, she ties many of the flavors to nearby growers, from strawberries out of the Cherokee-owned Miller Farms in Stilwell to pumpkins from the Cherokee Nation Heirloom Garden in Tahlequah that go into their Cherokee Pumpkin flavor, its name written in the Cherokee syllabary.
Inventive Flavors and Sorbets


Pure Joy makes everything from scratch, and you can taste it in the texture. There are no chemicals and very little air whipped in, which gives the ice cream a richer, denser scoop than the fluffy grocery-store stuff. Instead of starting with extracts or syrups, they build flavors from real ingredients, steeping actual lavender leaves, using real cocoa powder, and baking their own cookies for the cookies-and-cream.
Every flavor gets a twist, usually anchored to a local ingredient. The rotating lineup ranges from a Pawpaw & Lime sorbet, made from the native fruit and paired with pawpaw seeds they’ll sell you to grow your own, to the Happy Goat, a goat-cheese-and-honey scoop that eats more like cheesecake. Seasonal picks like the Cherokee Pumpkin rotate through, alongside favorites like Strawberry Lavender Sorbet, Midnight Mocha, Lavender Mint Chip, and a Blackout Lemonade sorbet for anyone skipping the dairy.
Beyond the scoops, there are milkshakes, floats, and other sweets. Samples are free, so you can taste your way through before you commit, and the waffle cones and bowls are pressed fresh.
Scott’s Thoughts


Pure Joy makes small-batch ice cream with locally sourced ingredients and is clearly quite popular because the line was out the door. We almost got gelato at Fratelli’s, but decided we wanted to support two local businesses in one evening, and we’re glad we did.
I got a waffle cone with a scoop of bourbon caramel swirl (made with dark beer from the nearby Ivory Bill Brewing Company and swirled with a house-made smoked-salt bourbon caramel) and a scoop of banana cream — both of which were excellent.
Charity tried the Cookie No Dough, a frozen-cookie-dough flavor with browned butter bits, brown sugar, and chocolate flakes from Bentonville’s Markham & Fitz, and the Fudge N Brownies, a rich chocolate ice cream loaded with fudgy brownies made from Markham & Fitz’s 70% dark chocolate.
The shop is very small inside and although they do have some barstool seating, the line itself is right on top of that seating so if you go while it’s busy your best bet will be to sit outside. That wasn’t bad since we went after dark, but in full sun it’s unfortunate.
Despite the cozy quarters, it’s well worth it for the excellent ice cream. We will definitely be coming back here next time we’re in Siloam Springs!
Frequently Asked Questions About Pure Joy Ice Cream
Where is Pure Joy Ice Cream?
Pure Joy Ice Cream is at 108 N Broadway St in downtown Siloam Springs, Arkansas 72761.
What are Pure Joy Ice Cream’s hours?
Monday through Saturday, noon to 10 p.m., and Sunday, 2 p.m. to 8 p.m.
What makes Pure Joy’s ice cream different?
Everything is made from scratch in small batches, with no chemicals and little air whipped in for a richer, denser texture. Each flavor is built around a real, often locally sourced ingredient, from area farms to the Cherokee Nation Heirloom Garden. Free samples let you taste before you choose, and the waffle cones are pressed fresh.
Does Pure Joy have dairy-free options?
Yes. Alongside the ice cream, Pure Joy makes sorbets, including flavors like the Blackout Lemonade and Pawpaw & Lime.
Can you buy Pure Joy Ice Cream outside the shop?
Yes. Pure Joy is carried by the pint and the scoop at spots across Northwest Arkansas, and single-serving cups are available by the case with delivery around the region.
